Abstract
Summary
The purpose of this work was to develop a model of factors affecting the glass rock of women's management in the Iranian sports organizations. The research method was the grounded theory with the Glaser approach. The targeted sampling method and the snowball technique were used for sampling for the in-depth interviews. A total of 13 interviews with experts were conducted, and continued until the research work reached a theoretical saturation and adequacy. The results obtained in order of priority of components were gender, social and cultural characteristics, psychological, organizational and managerial, personality differences, individual and family, and moral and legal, based on which the model of effective factors on the glass rock of women's management in the Iranian sports organizations was developed.
Introduction
The issue studied in the present work was why, although women make up half of the society's human resources and have the potential to increase the level of productivity of the society, their presence in the management jobs of the society, especially Iranian sports organizations, is insignificant. Due to the importance of the issue and in order to help the women sports community of our country, it is necessary to try to identify and eliminate the factors affecting the glass rock of women's management in the Iranian sports organizations. In this way, while identifying its causes, trying to take a deep and comprehensive look to provide the effective solutions, the bed of this rock is broken, and we see a more prominent presence of women in the middle and higher levels of management of our country's sports organizations in Iran.
Methodology and Approach
The research method applied in this work was a mixed explorative one (qualitative and quantitative). In the qualitative part of the research work, in order to present a systematic and schematic model (outline) of the findings from the coded data, the approach of grounded theory proposed by Glaser (1998) was used. The data was collected in the qualitative part using the interviews and reviewing documents, and in the quantitative part, using a questionnaire taken from the research model. The statistical population in this work included the senior managers of the Ministry of Sports and Youth, and presidents and members of federations and senior managers of the Department of Sports and Youth, National Olympic Committee and faculty members in the field of sports management, senior, middle, and operational managers of the Iranian sports organizations and club managers. After conducting 13 in-depth and semi-structured interviews with the statistical population of the research work, the main categories were extracted after completing the coding process. The purposeful and snowball sampling continued until a theoretical saturation. The reliability of the interviews was confirmed by the percentage of agreement within the topic. The data analysis results were obtained using the MaxQda qualitative analysis software in the three stages of open, axial, and theoretical coding. Then in the quantitative part, a questionnaire was distributed to 40 people among the sports professionals and elites, and the Friedman analysis of variance was used to rank the dimensions.
Results and Conclusion
In this work, the general framework of factors affecting the glass rock of women's management in the Iranian sports organizations was categorized including seven components, according to their prioritization and gender characteristics, social and cultural factors, psychological factors, organizational and managerial factors, personality differences, individual and family factors, and moral and legal factors. This analysis showed that these factors played a role in the formation of glass rock. It also indicated that the determinants were not necessarily related to one of the features, and were present in all features. Based on the presented model, it was identified that there were many obstacles to the advancement of women. These obstacles could be in the organizational, social, legal and political, cultural, economic, environmental, and media contexts. These barriers affect women's managerial roles, women's family responsibilities, and personality traits and psychology, which create a social pressure. These barriers create job interactions and interactions. These actions and interactions become two categories of individual and organizational barriers that individual barriers include lack of trust and self-confidence, inability to separate the family and organization environment, lack of risk-taking, fear of criticism, fear of accepting responsibility and organizational barriers including disability in networking, lack of authority in decision-making, lack of long-term vision and the reduction of communication links that the interaction of all these barriers leads to a gender-biased attitude in sports organizations, which has consequences including decreased motivation for progress, reduced job responsibility, negative community attitudes toward women, male-dominated attitudes, traditional attitudes toward women, unequal opportunities, gender inequality, and gender perspectives; all these obstacles are somehow an obstacle for women to progress and reach high managerial positions. It seems that in order to play the role of female managers in the country's sports, one of the key points to convince the top appointing authorities in sports is that based on the evidence, women have special, more, and better abilities in some soft skills such as human resource management and organizational behavior, which in today's conditions, these skills are required more than ever by the sports organizations in the country. The main goals based on achieving a proper performance were effective strategies and functional capabilities. This helps to understand how and why gender is important in the social and organizational process related to sport. However, beyond this theoretical fact, there is a truth rooted in the social, cultural and historical ideas and beliefs that link the concept of management with the concept of masculinity, and the first image that comes to mind from the manager is the concept of man. On the other hand, the presence of women in the sports organizations provides the basis for the development of a healthy culture and ethics. In general, it can be said that from the past until now, women's participation in sports decision-making and management of the country has been in an unfavorable situation, and its improvement in the future has gained a favorable momentum. The results of this research work can help the women's sports community of the country to shape a more favorable future for them.
Keywords
Main Subjects
- Mohaddes Khalesi SB. Promoting the position of women's organization, challenges, solutions. the first conference of social sciences, educational sciences, psychology and social security of Iran2017 (Persian).
- Wingfield HA. Racializing the Glass Escalator: Reconsidering Men's Experiences with Women's Work. Gender & Society. 2009;23(5):23-35.
- Burke RJ. Women in management and on corporate boards of directors: accelerating progress,In Women, Business and Leadership: Edward Elgar Publishing; 2019.
- Salvaj E, & Kuschel, K. Opening the “Black Box”: Factors Affecting Women’s Journey to Senior Management Positions—a Literature Review: Springer publication; 2019. 313-222.
- Tan BU. Women in Organizations: Challenges for Management. In Handbook of Research on Contemporary Approaches in Management and Organizational Strategy. IGI Global. 2019:207-25.
- Wagner C, Graells-Garrido, E., Garcia, D., & Menczer, F. Women through the glass ceiling: gender asymmetries in Wikipedia. EPJ Data Science. 2016; 5(1):19.
- Haghayegh MK, M A study of women's executive management performance in architecture and urban planning. Institute of Humanities and Cultural Studies 2019;1(2):37-11 (Persian).
- Stier HY, M. Occupational segregation and genderinequalityin job quality: a multi-level approach. Work, Employment & Society. 2014;28(2):225-46.
- Wynen. J. odB, S., & Ruebens. S. The Nexus between Gender and Perceived Career Opportunities Evidence from the U.S. Federal Government. Public Personnel Management. 2015; (3) :375-400.
- Velte P, Appointing female CEOs in risky and precarious firm circumstances A Review of the Glass Cliff Phenomenon. Corporate Ownership & Control. 2018;15(2):32-43.
- Yu HH. Glass Ceiling in Federal Law Enforcement: An Exploratory Analysis of the Factors Contributing to Women’s Career Advancement. Review of Public Personnel Administration. 2018;40(2):183-201.
- Amini Zare. S, Allah Khani S. women's job position in the light of glass roof theory. Journal of Psychological Studies and Educational Sciences. 2021;58:51-64. (Persian).
- Mehrara A, and Shafipour, S., and Dianti, R., and Zare Zaidi, A. Glass Ceiling, from Challenges and Solutions to Women's Empowerment. Shabak Magazine. 2017;29(14):57-69. (Persian(.
- Hamidizadeh, A. Seraji. R, Pourbehroozan A. Personal and institutional deterrents as the basis of the glass roof in the promotion of women in organizations. Journal of Women and Society. 2021;12(2):193-250 (Persian).
- Singh. V, Vinnicombe, S. The 2002 female FTSE index and females directors. Women in Management Review. 2003;18(7):349-58.
- Ryan, M. K.; Haslam, S. A.; Hersby, M. D.; Bongiorno, R. Think crisis–think female: The glass cliff and contextual variation in the think. Journal of Applied Psychology. 2010;96(3):470.
- Yaghi A. Glass Cliff or Glass Prison: Think Evil-Think Men in Organizational Leadership. International Journal of Public Administration. 2018;41(12):998-1008.
- Lumpkin A, Dodd, R. K., & McPherson, L. Does a Glass Ceiling Persist in Intercollegiate Athletics? Journal for the Study of Sports Athletes in Education,. 2014;8(1):33-46.
- Wirth L. Breaking through the glass ceiling. Women in management (Updated version in 2004 included). International Labour Organization (ILO). 2014;2(13):1-12.
- Galloway BJ. the glass ceiling: examining the advancement of women in the domain of athletic administration. McNair Scholars Research Journal. 2012;5(1):43-51.
- Ryan MK, Haslam, S. A., Morgenroth, T., Rink, F., Stoker, J., & Peters, K. Getting on top of the glass cliff: Reviewing a decade of evidence, explanations, and impact. The Leadership Quarterly. 2016;27(3):446-55.
- Shirzad Malabashi SF, A. Factors influencing the appointment of women to managerial positions in the Ministry of Sports and Youth with emphasis on the Sports Department. Ministry of Science, Research and Technology2017 (Persian).
- Jalsian R, Fahimi Nejad. A, Morsal B, Taybi Thani S M. The effect of leadership styles on job motivation mediated by women's glass rock phenomenon in sports in the Islamic Republic of Iran. Journal of Strategic Studies of Sports and Youth. 2021;20(51):135-52.( Persian).
- Fallah Ashnaabad F, Abbas Nazarian M.; Rasool Norouzi SH. Modeling the qualitative study of barriers affecting women's career and managerial promotion in Iranian sports organizations. Faculty of Physical Education and Sports Sciences: Tarbiat Dabir Shahid Rajaei University; 2019 (Persian).
- Seyed Javadin, S.; Jalilian; H. Management theories. Tehran: Negah Danesh Publications; 2017 (Persian).
- Mousavi rad S, Farahani, A., Bayat, P. Prioritization of Women Management Barriers in Sports by Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP). Applied Research in Sport Management. 2016;5(1):111-9 (Persian).
- Burrell DN, editor Developing more Women in Managerial Roles in Information Technology and Cybersecurity. Proceedings Midwest Association for Information Systems (MWAIS) 2019.
- Taj Maziani. A, Yaseri, Z. A Study of Women's Employment Policy in the Islamic Republic of Iran. Strategic Studies of Women 2014:47-58 (Persian(
- Rasekh, N.; Zareian, H.; Ghasemi, H.; Rezaei, Z. Iranian Women's Championship Sports: Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions. New approaches in sports science. 2012;1(1):99-116. (Persian).
- Al-Lahiari FB, H; Sajjadi, S N; Goodarzi, M, Ali Doust; Ghahfarkhi, E. The role of glass roof on the status of women's empowerment in Tehran Municipality Sports Organization. Journal of Applied Research in Sports Management. 2015;13:59.69. (Persian).
- Samaee. l, Ashraf Ganjavi. F, Azad Fada Sh, Poursoltani Zarandi, H. Predicting the empowerment of female employees of the Ministry of Sports and Youth of Iran based on the glass roof and organizational justice. Journal of Sports Science Scientific Research. 2021;12(40):32 -47. (Persian).
- Esfidani MR. Barriers to women's access to management positions. Women's Research Quarterly. 2002;1(4):67-85. (Persian)
- Rezapour M, ghahramani, J., abbaszadeh sohroun, Y. Identifying the Factors of Glass Ceiling Formation to Promote Women in Management Positions in the Iran. Quarterly Journal of Women and Society 2021;11(44):93-116. (Persian).
- Molaei P, Alvani, S., zahedi, S., Alinejad, A. A meta-analysis on the obstacles to women's promotion to the levels of governance in Iranian government agencies. Journal of Career and Organizational Counseling. 2021;12(42):199-224. (Persian)
- Mirghfouri SH. Identifying and ranking the effective factors in not appointing women to managerial positions in government organizations in Yazd province. Journal of Social-Psychological Studies of Women (Women's Studies) 2006;4(1):101-22. ( Persian).
- Cotter DA, Hermsen, J. M., Ovadia S., & Vanneman R. The glass ceiling effect. Social Forces. 2010;80(2): 655–81.
- Zargar .T, editor Glass Roof Syndrome: Challenges for women in managerial positions in sports organizations. First National Congress of Successful Iranian Women; 2016; Tehran: Datis International Development Conference Center. (Persian)
- Pesyan G. Study of identifying the factors that form the glass roof over women in organizations. the third national conference on management and humanities; Jiroft: Gostaran Conference; 2017 (Persian).
- Kazemipour S. Women and management in higher education (barriers and solutions). In: University SCoEWot, editor. Conference on Women and Management in Higher Education; Tehran: Islamic Azad University, South Tehran Branch; 2015; 1-15 ( Persian).
- Soleiman Pour-Omran MY, T; Talebzadeh, A. Women Management and Social Capital Development. Fourth International Conference on Applied Research in Management and Accounting; Shahid Beheshti University of Tehran.2016 (Persian).
- Bruckmuller S, Ryan, M. & Rink, F. Beyond the Glass Ceiling: The Glass Cliff and Its Lessons for Organizational Policy. Social Issues and Policy Review. 2014;8(1):202–32.
- Margaret LM, H. Female Sport Leaders Perception of Leadership and Management:Skills and Attitudes for success’. Seattle University Global Sport Business Journal. 2014;2) 1).
- Zarghamifard MB, MR A Study of Women's Experiences and Challenges in Organizational Leadership Positions. Organizational Culture Management. 2014;12(2):32-40 (Persian).
- Morrison A, and von Glinow, M A. Women and minorities in management. american psychologist 1990;95(2):200-8.
- Schwartz R. Support from Above the Glass Ceiling: Narratives of Women as University Student Leaders 2019.
- Shetab Bushehri NE, M; Kuchkian, H .; Mishabaki Esfahani, A. Study and ranking of factors preventing the promotion of women to managerial positions in Khuzestan sports committees. Sports Science Research. 2009;6(19):171-89 ( Persian)
- Kim P, Juliana M, Molly R. Recommendedcttation: Women and Leadership: Public Says Women are Equally Qualified but Barriers Persist. Washington, DC: Pew Research Center. 2015.
- Mottaqi Shahri M.; Ghafouri, F.; Mahmoudi, A. Comparison of the role and presence of women in managerial positions in sports and non-sports organizations New approaches in sports management. 2014;2(4):9-20 (Persian)
- Schulpen T. The glass ceiling:A biological phenomenon. Medical hypotheses. 2017:41-3.
- Bonyan A, and Kashef, M. Differences in legal awareness and civil liability of male and female sports coaches in sporting events. Applied Research in Sports Management. 2014;2(4):79-90. (Persian)
- Sedaghat GA. A study of the conditions and restrictions of women's labor rights from the perspective of jurisprudence and law. Journal of Knowledge. 2007;16(118):97-111.(Persian).